Once you've found where a draft is actually coming from, the next mistake is just as common: buying a draft stopper sized by guesswork instead of a real measurement, then dealing with cold air sneaking through the gaps it misses on either end. The short answer: measure the full width of the gap plus a little extra for overlap, and measure the gap's depth too — not just its width.
Why "it looks about right" doesn't work here
A draft stopper that's even half an inch short on either side leaves an open channel for cold air to keep coming through — which defeats the purpose of buying one in the first place. Doors and windows aren't always perfectly square either, so a stopper that fits snugly on one side can still gap on the other if the frame has settled slightly over time, which is common in older homes.
Measuring width: the number that actually matters
Measure the full width of the door or window opening at its widest point, not just where the gap currently looks biggest. Add roughly an inch to that measurement if you're buying an adjustable or trimmable stopper — a little extra length you can trim down is a much easier fix than a stopper that's already too short out of the box.
Don't skip depth
Width gets the attention, but the gap's depth (how far back the stopper needs to reach, especially under a door with a raised threshold or an uneven sill) determines whether the stopper actually seals or just sits on top of the gap without closing it. A door with a deep threshold gap needs a stopper with enough profile to actually fill that depth, not just span the width.
Doors vs. windows: different gap shapes entirely
A door's gap runs in a straight horizontal line along the bottom. A window sill's gap often isn't a clean straight line at all — older window frames can have slight variation across their width, which is part of why a dedicated window sill stopper (built longer and sometimes adjustable) handles this better than a generic door-style stopper repurposed for a window.
For a long window sill specifically, the Window Sill Draft Stopper (47 inches) is built for exactly this gap shape — measure your actual sill length against its 47-inch span before assuming a shorter door-style stopper will cover it.
A quick way to confirm you measured right
Once installed, run the same hand test from Monday's check (slowly moving your hand along the full length of the stopper) — if you still feel air at either end, the stopper was either measured short or the gap isn't actually straight enough for a simple stopper to seal completely.
Before you buy, check this
- Measure the full gap width at its widest point, and add roughly an inch of margin if the stopper is trimmable
- Measure the gap's depth, not just its width — especially for thresholds with any raised lip
- Check whether you're dealing with a door (straight gap) or a window sill (often less uniform), and pick the stopper type built for that shape
- Re-run the hand test after installing to confirm there's no air leaking at either end
Conclusion
A draft stopper only works if it's measured to the gap's real width and depth, not estimated by eye — measure both, then check the Draft Stoppers collection for a size (or trimmable option) that actually matches what you measured.